Skip to main content

Case Study: SAP HANA Mapping Engines for Business Rules in ETL Loads for Mass Data Processing

Executive Summary

This case study examines the capabilities of SAP HANA’s mapping engines for implementing business rules in ETL processes for mass data processing scenarios. We analyze both native SAP solutions and third-party products, evaluating their performance, scalability, and suitability for enterprise-level data transformation requirements. The study includes real-world implementation examples, comparative analysis, and recommendations for different business contexts.

1. Introduction

As organizations deal with ever-increasing volumes of data, efficient ETL (Extract, Transform, Load) processes have become critical for business intelligence and analytics. SAP HANA, as an in-memory computing platform, offers powerful capabilities for processing large datasets. However, implementing complex business rules and data mapping within ETL processes remains a challenge for many enterprises.

This case study focuses on how organizations can effectively implement business rules in SAP HANA-based ETL processes for mass data processing, examining both native SAP solutions and third-party alternatives.

2. Understanding SAP HANA’s Native Mapping Capabilities
2.1 SAP HANA Smart Data Integration (SDI)

SAP HANA Smart Data Integration provides real-time data integration capabilities with flowgraph-based transformations. It allows for complex data mapping and transformation rules within the SAP HANA environment.

2.2 SAP HANA Smart Data Quality (SDQ)

SAP HANA Smart Data Quality extends SDI with comprehensive data cleansing, validation, and enrichment functionalities. It provides a rule-based approach to ensure data quality during ETL processes.

2.3 SAP HANA Rules Framework

The SAP HANA Rules Framework allows for the definition and execution of business rules directly within the SAP HANA environment. These rules can be incorporated into ETL processes to enforce business logic during data transformations.

3. Third-Party Mapping Engines and Extensions
3.1 Informatica PowerCenter with HANA Connectivity

Informatica PowerCenter offers robust integration with SAP HANA, providing advanced mapping capabilities and business rule implementation. Its high-performance architecture is designed for processing massive datasets while applying complex transformation logic.

3.2 IBM InfoSphere DataStage

IBM InfoSphere DataStage offers parallel processing capabilities for ETL workloads with SAP HANA connectivity. It excels in handling complex business rules for large-scale data transformations and provides comprehensive lineage tracking.

3.3 Talend Data Integration

Talend’s open-source approach provides cost-effective integration with SAP HANA. It offers a graphical development environment for creating mapping rules and transformations, with support for native HANA operations.

3.4 Qlik Replicate (formerly Attunity)

Qlik Replicate specializes in real-time data integration with SAP HANA, offering change data capture (CDC) capabilities with minimal impact on source systems. Its rule-based transformation engine supports complex mapping requirements.

3.5 CData SSIS Components for SAP HANA

CData provides SSIS integration components that allow Microsoft SQL Server Integration Services to connect with SAP HANA, enabling the use of familiar SSIS tools for mapping and business rule implementation.

4. Case Examples
Case Example 1: Global Manufacturing Company

Challenge: A global manufacturing company needed to consolidate financial data from 50+ ERP systems into SAP HANA for real-time reporting, applying complex currency conversion and inter-company reconciliation rules.

Solution: The company implemented SAP HANA SDI in conjunction with Informatica PowerCenter to handle the complex business rules. Informatica handled the initial extraction and heavy transformation, while HANA SDI managed the final loading and real-time transformations.

Results:

  • Reduced processing time by 72% compared to previous ETL solution
  • Improved data quality by centralizing business rule definitions
  • Enabled dynamic pricing optimization based on demand patterns
Case Example 2: International Retail Chain

Challenge: A retail chain with 2,000+ stores needed to process point-of-sale transaction data for inventory management, applying complex pricing and promotion rules across different regions.

Solution: The retailer implemented Talend Data Integration with SAP HANA, utilizing Talend for extraction and complex rule processing, while leveraging HANA’s in-memory capabilities for analytical processing.

Results:

  • Processed 15+ million daily transactions with business rules applied in near real-time
  • Reduced stockouts by 23% through timely inventory insights
  • Enabled dynamic pricing optimization based on demand patterns
Case Example 3: Healthcare Provider Network

Challenge: A healthcare network needed to integrate patient data from multiple systems while applying complex privacy rules, data masking, and regulatory compliance checks.

Solution: The organization implemented SAP HANA with its native Rules Framework, supplemented by SAP SDQ for data quality enforcement.

Results:

  • Achieved 99.8% data accuracy while maintaining full regulatory compliance
  • Reduced data integration time from days to hours
  • Created a unified patient view while enforcing sophisticated access control rules
5. Comparative Analysis
Solution Performance for Mass Data Business Rules Complexity Integration Ease Cost Considerations Best Suited For
SAP HANA SDI/SDQ High (in-memory advantage) Medium High for SAP ecosystem Included with HANA license SAP-centric organizations with moderate rule complexity
SAP HANA Rules Framework High Medium-High High for SAP ecosystem Included with HANA license Organizations requiring rules governance within HANA
Informatica PowerCenter Very High Very High Medium High Enterprise-scale implementations with complex transformations
IBM InfoSphere DataStage Very High High Medium High Organizations with existing IBM investments
Talend Data Integration Medium-High High Medium-High Medium (open-source options) Cost-sensitive implementations with mixed environments
Qlik Replicate High (especially for CDC) Medium High Medium-High Real-time data synchronization scenarios
CData SSIS Components Medium Medium High for Microsoft shops Low Microsoft-centric environments with existing SSIS skills
6. Key Findings
Advantages of Native SAP HANA Solutions
  • Seamless integration with SAP ecosystem
  • In-memory processing advantages for performance
  • Lower total cost for organizations already invested in SAP
  • Simplified architecture with fewer integration points
  • SAP support and roadmap alignment
Advantages of Third-Party Solutions
  • More sophisticated mapping and transformation capabilities
  • Better handling of heterogeneous environments
  • More mature metadata management and lineage
  • Often more user-friendly interfaces for business users
  • Specialized functionality for specific use cases
7. Recommendations
7.1 For SAP-Centric Organizations

Organizations deeply invested in the SAP ecosystem should first evaluate SAP HANA’s native capabilities (SDI, SDQ, and Rules Framework). For scenarios with moderate complexity, these solutions provide the best integration and total cost of ownership. For specific high-complexity requirements, consider augmenting with targeted third-party tools.

7.2 For Organizations with Complex Heterogeneous Environments

Organizations with diverse system landscapes should consider enterprise-grade tools like Informatica PowerCenter or IBM InfoSphere DataStage, which excel at complex transformations across multiple platforms while still integrating effectively with SAP HANA.

7.3 For Mid-Market Organizations

Mid-market companies should evaluate Talend or CData solutions, which offer a good balance of functionality and cost-effectiveness, particularly when technical resources are limited or cost constraints are significant.

7.4 For Real-Time Requirements

Organizations requiring near real-time data processing should focus on SAP HANA’s native capabilities combined with Qlik Replicate for change data capture, providing an optimal solution for time-sensitive business rules application.

8. Implementation Best Practices
  • Business Rule Governance: Establish a central repository for business rules to ensure consistency across transformation processes.
  • Performance Optimization: For mass data processing, implement partitioning strategies and leverage HANA’s columnar storage structure.
  • Hybrid Approach: Consider a hybrid architecture where complex initial transformations occur in specialized ETL tools before loading to HANA for final business rule application.
  • Rules Testing Framework: Develop a comprehensive testing framework for business rules to validate behavior with sample datasets.
  • Monitoring and Logging: Implement detailed monitoring of rule execution to identify performance bottlenecks and rule failures.
9. Conclusion

SAP HANA provides powerful capabilities for implementing business rules in ETL processes for mass data processing. While native SAP solutions offer advantages in terms of integration and performance within the SAP ecosystem, third-party tools bring specialized capabilities for complex transformations and heterogeneous environments.

The optimal approach depends on an organization’s specific requirements, existing technology investments, and the complexity of business rules being implemented. Many successful implementations leverage a combination of native SAP capabilities and third-party tools to achieve the best balance of performance, functionality, and cost-effectiveness.

As data volumes continue to grow and business rules become increasingly complex, organizations should regularly reassess their ETL architecture to ensure it remains aligned with evolving business requirements and technology capabilities.

Latest Articles